Testing 22 AI Writers for SEO: The Results Will Surprise You!

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Testing AI Writers for SEO Friendliness
3. Part 1: Generating Content with Keyword Intents and Difficulties
   1. High Difficulty Keyword Testing
   2. Medium Difficulty Keyword Testing
   3. Low Competition Keyword Testing
4. Part 2: Case Study of AI Writers and Content Agencies
5. Tools Used for Testing SEO Friendliness
6. Surfer SEO: An Overview
7. Results of AI Writer Testing
   1. Longshot.ai
   2. Jasper AI
   3. Chat GPT-4
   4. Copy AI
   5. WriteSonic
   6. Koala
   7. Wordplay.ai
   8. Autoblogging.ai
   9. Seori.ai
   10. Draft Horse AI
8. Pros and Cons of AI Writers
9. Recommendations and Conclusion

🖋️ Testing AI Writers for SEO Friendliness

In the world of content creation, AI writers have gained popularity for their ability to generate text quickly and efficiently. As an SEO enthusiast, I was curious to find out which AI writer is the most SEO-friendly. After testing 22 of the most popular AI writers, I have come up with the results to save you the time and effort. In this article, I will share my findings from the first part of the test, where I focused on generating content with different keyword intents and difficulties. Additionally, I will provide an overview of the tools used for determining the SEO friendliness of the generated content, such as Surfer SEO. So, let's dive into the world of AI writers and their SEO performance.

Part 1: Generating Content with Keyword Intents and Difficulties

High Difficulty Keyword Testing

In order to assess the SEO friendliness of AI writers, I targeted high difficulty keywords related to specific topics. By utilizing tools like Ahrefs, I was able to identify keywords with a difficulty score of 90+ that would challenge the AI writers. These keywords were carefully chosen to represent buyer intent, comparison, and informational intent. The generated content was evaluated using Surfer SEO, a tool that provides a comprehensive analysis of over 500 signals to determine SEO performance.

Medium Difficulty Keyword Testing

In addition to high difficulty keywords, I also tested AI writers with medium difficulty keywords. These keywords focused on topics such as office chairs, gaming chairs, and upholstery. The goal was to assess how well the AI writers could handle less competitive keywords while maintaining SEO friendliness.

Low Competition Keyword Testing

To further evaluate the SEO friendliness of AI writers, I tested them with low competition keywords. These keywords centered around specific types of chairs, such as task chairs and Adirondack chairs. By targeting less competitive keywords, I aimed to gauge the AI writers' ability to excel in less saturated niches.

Part 2: Case Study of AI Writers and Content Agencies

After assessing the SEO performance of AI writers in generating content, the second part of the test involved creating websites targeting the same keywords for each AI writer and content agency. This case study aimed to identify which AI writer or content agency would rank highest in search engine results. By comparing their performance, we can gain valuable insights into the effectiveness of AI writers in achieving SEO success.

Tools Used for Testing SEO Friendliness

To evaluate the SEO friendliness of the generated content, I utilized two powerful tools: Surfer SEO and Ahrefs. Surfer SEO analyzes numerous signals to provide a real-time assessment of a page's compatibility with Google's guidelines. By utilizing Surfer SEO's AI-driven analysis, we were able to determine the SEO scores of the content generated by the AI writers. Ahrefs, on the other hand, offered invaluable keyword research capabilities necessary to identify high difficulty, medium difficulty, and low competition keywords.

Results of AI Writer Testing

During the testing phase, each AI writer was evaluated based on their SEO score, buyer guide keywords, and informational keywords. Let's take a closer look at the performance of some of the AI writers that were tested:

1. Longshot.ai

Longshot.ai proved to be a challenging AI writer to work with. With a multi-step process that took approximately five minutes to generate an article and a low SEO score of 26 out of 100, it fell to the bottom of the list.

2. Jasper AI

Despite its high valuation and popularity, Jasper AI underperformed in the AI writer test. It struggled to generate SEO-friendly content, resulting in an average SEO score of 30. Both its buyer intent and informational keywords scored around 30 as well, making it a disappointing choice for SEO-focused content.

3. Koala

Koala emerged as the top AI writer for SEO friendliness, particularly excelling in generating buyer guide content. With competitive pricing starting at nine dollars a month, Koala offered an affordable option with an average SEO score of 66. Its buyer guide keywords scored highest among the AI writers tested, making it a compelling choice for affiliate marketers.

These are just a few examples of the AI writers tested, and the full report can be downloaded for more detailed insights.

Pros and Cons of AI Writers

While AI writers offer speed and efficiency in content generation, it is important to consider the pros and cons before deciding to utilize their services. Let's take a closer look at the advantages and disadvantages of using AI writers:

Pros:

• Faster content creation: AI writers can generate content at a much faster rate compared to human writers.
• Cost-effective: With affordable pricing plans available, AI writers can be a more affordable option for content creation.
• SEO optimization: Some AI writers are designed with built-in SEO optimization, allowing for SEO-friendly content creation.

Cons:

• Lack of personal touch: AI-generated content may lack the human touch and creativity that comes with human-written content.
• Limited cognitive abilities: AI writers may struggle with more complex topics that require critical thinking and creativity.
• Quality and accuracy concerns: While AI writers have made significant advancements, there is still a risk of grammatical errors and inaccurate information in the generated content.

Recommendations and Conclusion

Based on the testing and evaluation of AI writers, Koala emerged as the top choice for SEO-friendly content generation, especially for buyer guide keywords. With its competitive pricing and impressive SEO scores, Koala proves to be a reliable option for marketers looking to create SEO-friendly content efficiently. However, it's essential to consider your specific needs and requirements when choosing an AI writer. Each AI writer has its own strengths and weaknesses, so thorough evaluation and testing are necessary before making a final decision.

In conclusion, AI writers have the potential to revolutionize the content creation process, but they should be used as a tool rather than a complete replacement for human writers. By harnessing the power of AI and combining it with human creativity, marketers can achieve optimal results in their content marketing strategies. So, don't hesitate to explore the world of AI writers and find the one that best fits your SEO and content creation needs!

Highlights

1. AI writers offer speed and efficiency in content generation, but it's important to consider their pros and cons before deciding to use them.
2. Surfer SEO and Ahrefs are valuable tools for testing the SEO friendliness of AI-generated content.
3. Koala emerged as the top AI writer for SEO friendliness, particularly excelling in generating buyer guide content.
4. Thorough evaluation and testing are necessary when choosing an AI writer, as each has its own strengths and weaknesses.
5. Utilizing AI writers as a tool alongside human creativity can lead to optimal results in content marketing strategies.

FAQ

Q: Are AI writers better than human writers for SEO-friendly content? A: AI writers offer speed and efficiency in content generation, but they may lack the human touch and creativity that comes with human-written content. While AI writers can excel in generating SEO-friendly content, it's important to consider your specific needs and requirements before making a decision.

Q: What are the advantages of using AI writers? A: Some advantages of using AI writers include faster content creation, cost-effectiveness, and the potential for built-in SEO optimization that can aid in generating SEO-friendly content.

Q: Can AI writers handle complex topics? A: AI writers may struggle with more complex topics that require critical thinking and creativity, as their cognitive abilities are limited. It's important to evaluate the capabilities of AI writers and consider their suitability for your specific content needs.

Q: How should I choose the right AI writer for my needs? A: Thorough evaluation and testing are necessary when choosing an AI writer. Consider factors such as pricing, SEO scores, and the ability to generate content for your specific keyword intents and difficulties. Each AI writer has its own strengths and weaknesses, so it's important to choose one that aligns with your requirements.